May 2004 Issue
 
Click Here for Larger Image

 

This 12-1/4 inch tile, designed by Addison LeBoutiller and decorated with the cuenca technique, shows a large oak tree, green grass, puffy ivory clouds and blue sky. An accomplished architectural draughtsman and illustrator, LeBoutiller replaced George Kendrick as director of design in 1902. Though only a part-time employee, he was to create about 150 designs over the next (about) nine years including all those that modern collectors perceive as “Grueby tiles.” The oak tree scenic was very popular, the significance of this example being its exceptionally large size. It sold in January 2003 for $37,500. 

Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions, Lambertville, NJ.

 

 

 

 

 

Click Images for Larger View

 

 

Click Here for Larger View

Right: This rare 10-inch two-color vase shows tooled and applied stylized flowers in chartreuse covered with an excellent dark green matte glaze. Grueby's earliest art ware was always in a single color, the addition of a second, and very occasionally a third color, only coming after the turn of the century. Rarer, these pots have established something of a “pecking order” in today's market. Though exceptions exist, a smallish two-color vessel will typically command a much higher price than a larger, better modeled example carrying only one. This vase sold in September 2002 for $8,750. 
Photo courtesy
Craftsman Auctions, Lambertville, NJ.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Click Images for Larger View

 

 
Click Here for Larger View

Large and exceptional 17 3/4" two-color vase very sharply modeled by Wilhemina Post. While size is one factor in determining the relative desirability of a Grueby example, it only becomes pivotal in the presence of other factors.  Here, graceful form, two colors, exquisite modeling and perfect firing achieve importance as found on a very large example.  This significance was fully realized, as the piece reached a record price of $80,000. Sold September 2001. 
Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions, Lambertville, NJ.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Click Images for Larger View

 

 

Grueby The View from 100 Years...By Steve Fales

          "To me there is more true art in a brick made and burnt by one man than there is in the best piece of molded pottery ever made" – William J. Walley

The World's Columbian Exposition took place in Chicago in 1893.

            If you were thinking of traveling there from Boston you would likely inquire into the routes and destinations offered by the “Iron Horse,” a descriptor that had gained new currency since the riotous visit of  Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show. At a time when the “Wild West” was generally felt to begin somewhere in Ohio, and the railroad experience not exactly perfected, you really had to want to go.

            William Henry Grueby, a native of Chelsea, did. And what he was to see there, coupled with a novel opaque matte glaze he had developed, would lead several years later to the ceramic treasures we today simply call “Grueby.” The most important baggage 26 year-old “Will” took on his journey was his knowledge of ceramic processes and glaze chemistry, and an interest in new applications for his coveted glaze. For the previous 13 years, his training ground and focus had been tiles and architectural installations, first at the nearby J & JG Low Art Tile Works and then – at the time of his trek – his own Grueby and Atwood firm.

             "Grueby's glazes were the direct result of the combined practical knowledge of the Robertsons and John Gardner Low."  –Susan Montgomery, The Ceramics of William H. Grueby

            During his ten-year stay at Low (beginning in 1880, when he was just 13) he was encouraged to experiment with glazes and gained the considerable knowledge of the Low establishment. He also enjoyed the glazing insights of the Chelsea Keramic Art Works through association with George Robertson, who had moved over to the Low Works from that firm.

 

A New Partnership and a New Art

             Inspired by what he had seen at the Exposition – specifically the hand-thrown avante garde work of the French potter August Delaherche – he entered a new partnership in 1894 with the stated purpose of developing hollow ware (i.e art pottery). The Grueby Faience Company would ultimately be incorporated in 1897.

            "The shapes distinguished Grueby ware every bit as much as the glaze, as they depended not on intricacy or elaborateness of design and ornamentation, but rather on integrity and contour" – Paul Evans, Art Pottery of the United States

            Of his choice of two partners, that of George Prentiss Kendrick as his designer proved to be of considerable consequence. Kendrick, a member of Boston's Arts & Crafts Society, was a skilled metal smith and architectural draughtsman – and more, someone with a particular and very personal fascination for flowers and leaf forms. Kendrick was not a potter. His simple sketches, developed freely, intuitively, and without particular thought to their “do-ability” in the ceramic context, became the loose blueprints for organic and sensuous hand thrown and tooled pottery forms. These were uncannily appropriate to Grueby's glaze and are today considered every bit as superior. 

 

So what makes Grueby so special, so valuable?

            "To my mind, George Ohr and Grueby are perhaps the two best expressions of the Arts and Crafts philosophy. Grueby, though a collaborative affair and a small factory, defined an aesthetic in a very singular way, one that resonated deeply in America."David Rago

            While we might single out the ware's simple, elegant. and beautifully contoured forms or its true-to-the-sense-of-life modeling, it was quite clear to Grueby himself what was most important about his product. And that was its glaze. Evidencing his thinking was the disposition of two Grueby pieces shown at the Worcester Art Museum's exhibition of 1903:

 

 

This Grueby lamp base has an original Tiffany Acorn pattern leaded glass shade. William Grueby supplied lamp bases for Louis Tiffany, as well as tiles for the tops of various Gustav Stickley tables.  It is believed that mutual respect existed between the three, based upon the quality of their respective creations and the values of the Arts and Crafts Movement that spawned them. The hand made, organic and sometimes sensuous nature of Grueby bases were remarkably compatible with many of Tiffany's designs and lighting effects. This example sold January 2001 for $32,500.
Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions,
Lambertville, NJ.

             "Two pieces were selected for the museum's permanent collection: a vase in light blue for $12 (and another for $100). The vases are nearly identical in size, approximately twelve inches, and form. The reason for the $88 difference in the value placed upon them by Grueby was in the glazes." Susan Montgomery, The Ceramics of William H. Grueby

            Grueby pots cooled to an incredible range of glaze effects, particularly vivid in green and unmatched by any other pottery. These, animating the surfaces of pots themselves showing the subtle variations wrought by hand work, guaranteed that no two pieces were ever exactly alike. Opaque, often thick and typically of low luster, Grueby “green” ranged from a dark, rich, and relatively even finish to all manner of highly complex curdled, crackled, veined speckled, and even crystalline effects. A single superior example, studied close-up, might carry virtually every shade of the color, from black/green spots and flecks to a soft yellow where the glaze eased away from high points to reveal the underlying clay. These variations were part of the idea, as were the subtle differences in modeling – evidence of the ”entirely by the hands of man” nature of the ware. Ware that was entirely consistent with the varied natural world it sought to praise and often captured.

            Put another way, it was a timely and perfect response to the repeatability and cookie-cutter uniformity sought by industrialists and mass marketers – whether those of 1880, those creating cheap green pottery in the 1903-1918 period or, for that matter, the monster California agri-growers of today. All were, and are, essentially anti-natural. Oranges may look better now but, be sure, they tasted better then.

 

Artistic Success and a Flock of Imitators

            Grueby's art pottery was first exhibited and sold in Boston in 1897. A sensation from the first, it achieved major international acclaim within three years – a rapid rise to prominence by today's standards, astonishing given the pace of the times.

            It was decorative art, and it was expensive.

            Important awards kept piling up and, by 1904, the pottery had reached its zenith in stature and production. Even by then, though, the seeds of the Pottery's ultimate departure from the art pottery arena (about 1910) had already taken root. Ironically, the firm had planted them itself. Its highly visible success – and its coincidental contribution to popularizing the color green – had already encouraged other potteries to create and begin marketing less expensive “green pots” of their own as early as 1903, many aping the Grueby look.

            Some major potteries, including Hampshire, Wheatley, Teco, and Owens, were to deliberately cast Grueby look-alikes complete with yellow “buds.” Others, including Weller, Roseville, and McCoy, dedicated whole lines to more easily afforded matte green ware.

            "Ultimately, more than 100 studios and companies imitated [Grueby's] style and glazes, and this was no accident. Cashing in on Grueby's success seemed an obvious move."David Rago

 

This very late and very rare 4-1/4 by 9-inch squat vessel in yellow, green, and dark green shows very precise decoration and perfect glazing, this example is of particular interest on two counts: it represents the relative handful of three-color expressions manufactured; and it was created in 1914 when historical records indicate the firm was dedicated to tiles – this, some four years after the company had announced it would no longer be producing art ware. It sold in September 2002 for $47,500.  Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions,
Lambertville, NJ.

 

            Some of these glazes were excellent, but most were little more than a dip job. It really didn't matter: Their cumulative effect was to increasingly saturate the market with more or less valid choices -- all of them “green,” the vast majority priced well below Grueby. Significantly, only a very few potteries had an investment in green that rivaled Grueby's. For most, this color was merely a new profit center, a trendy add on to already varied product lines. Grueby offered no such variety, its ware regardless of basic color, form, or modeling being perceived correctly as a single aesthetic, a single kind of pottery.

            Thus, the company's art pottery business plateaued, then gradually withered in the 1904-1908 period – a decline hastened by increasing competition, an ever more crowded field, rather like a giant being slowly nibbled to death by rabbits. Under severe financial pressure by 1907, the firm's art pottery end received something of a death blow when
major production problems developed. Both
the art pottery and tile businesses came to a virtual standstill for nearly a year. Orders
went unfilled, customers found satisfaction elsewhere, and the company fell into receivership.

            It ultimately resurfaced as still another corporate entity – and thrived – as a firm once again, as in the beginning, dedicated exclusively to tiles and architectural installations. But the art pottery era was over.

 

The View from Now

            Grueby looks and feels as good today as it did 100 years ago, and one might wonder not so much how it found critical favor at the time, but why it has never lost it.

            It is perhaps more than merely interesting that many advanced pottery collectors today are convinced that great hand made art pottery is literally alive. That it in some inexplicable way it seems to pulse with and radiate a certain energy that, to them, is quite apparent.

            Among American makers the work of George Ohr, Newcomb College, and WJ Walley come to mind immediately in this regard – as does Grueby in a big way. The best works of each, as different as they are, share much common ground. They were created primarily out of an artistic impulse, entirely by hand, honestly, and with a keen respect for the materials. (Fortunately for us, the Gods also bequeathed commercial viability on them, at least for a time.)

Left Above: This 5-inch vase modeled by Ruth Erickson shows narrow green buds against an oatmealed blue glaze. This small vase represents a highly unusual form and color combination, green against blue being very seldom seen. In the world of Grueby collectors, the unusual often translates into a willingness to pay high prices. It sold May 2002 for $15,000. Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions, Lambertville, NJ.

Middle Above: This 8-inch square tile depicts Saint George Slaying the Dragon and shows curdled matte glazes in greens, ambers, blues, and ivory.  Almost certainly designed by Addison LeBoutiller, the work is decorated in cuenca and cuerda seca, (“cuenca” referring to a cloisonne-like technique). The pattern was pressed into the surface of the tile, creating small valleys into which the glaze was painstakingly applied by hand. Historical themes were not uncommon in Grueby's very extensive tile lineup. Given the nature of the process and the variability of glaze effects, the finished product often had a strongly impressionistic feeling. Tile sold in September 2003 for $21,000.  Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions, Lambertville, NJ.

Right Above: This 6-1/4-inch square bowl was modeled by Wilhelmina Post and decorated with applied and tooled leaves. Only about 20 percent of Grueby's hollow ware carried the initials of the modeler, in this instance “WP.” Post, along with a handful of others including Ruth Erickson and Marie Seaman, was considered a superior modeler. In today's market, the presence of a recognizable modeler's initials adds a small premium to the value of otherwise comparable examples. This bowl sold January 2003 for $3,000.  Photo courtesy Craftsman Auctions, Lambertville, NJ.
 

            The size of the accomplishment, though – and that curious energy – seems to beg a further explanation. This, simply because the finished products were of far greater consequence than they might have been, somehow more powerful than all the talents and good intentions that went into them. For those with a spiritual bent it is tempting to speculate that, once the kiln door closed and the heat came up, the various players had no choice but to stand back and wait...on Nature Herself to look in, smile her approval, and actively fuse and energize the pottery, once and for all time.

            And so, perhaps, She did.

 

Steve Fales has been closely associated with the field of Arts and Crafts for 25 years. A writer, publicist, and advanced art pottery collector, he is the former Arts and Crafts editor of this publication.

         

 
 

Journal Home Page     Contents Page     Brimfield FleaMarkets.Com     Brimfield Country Store     Subscribe