January
 2003 Issue
By James C. Johnston Jr.
Photos by Steven Vater

 


    James C. Johnston Jr. was born in the historic Oliver Pond House in Franklin, Massachusetts where he has lived for 58 years. He holds B.A. and M.A. degrees in History and is the author of several books. He has also written more than 1,500 articles and monographs in The Numismatist, Linn’s Stamp News, The Regional Recorder, and other publications.
  
   Johnston was a teacher in the Franklin system for 34 years and has been associated with Johnston Antiques since 1962. He is a well known appraiser of antiques, books, fine arts, stamps, and coins. He is a founding member of the Massachusetts Suburban Antique Dealers Association, a member of the American Numismatic Association, and the American Philatelic Society. He has also been President of the Franklin Historical Society since 1985.

    Johnston is also a well known lecturer whose topics cover a wide range of social history, antiques, coins, stamps, and the fine arts, as well as, politics and political and military history.


   I hope to see you all at the N.E.S.S. Show in Dedham, Mass. on Sunday, December 1 at the Holiday Inn. The Holiday Inn is located at the junction of Routes 1 and 128 (Exit 15A). The show hours are 9am to 3:30pm. I’ll also be back in Auburn on Sunday, December 8 at the Ramada Inn (off Exit 10 from the Mass. Turnpike) at Tom Lacey’s Greater Worcester Coin Show. I always enjoy meeting all of you Journal readers there to “talk coins”.

      Have a great and safe Holiday Season.

    You can also log onto my website at www.johnstonantiques.com 
for further updates.
 

 

The Numismatic Heritage of New York

            New York has a great numismatic history.  Founded by the Dutch in the 1620s, New Amsterdam, as New York was first known, became a great commercial center.  Large Dutch thalers circulated in this rich colony as did gold ducats.

             In 1664, the British took over New Amsterdam as a result of a war that found the Netherlands pitted against the English. James Stuart, Duke of York and younger brother of King Charles II of England, was given this colony that became his namesake.

            Now English pounds, crowns, shillings, and pennies joined the Dutch and German thalers and the ubiquitous Spanish pieces-of-eight then in circulation.

            New York grew during the colonial period as a cosmopolitan center for shipping, trade, printing, banking, some manufacturing, and even theater.  The British occupied it during most of the American Revolution.  It was a Tory town, to a certain degree as a matter of convenience, but after the evacuation of the British, it was found to be quite a patriotic center.  For a time it was the capital of the United States.  As a matter of fact, Washington was first sworn in as president in 1789 at New York’s City hall.

            A lot of pirate loot made its way into New York. Captain William Kidd, of pirate fame, entered into any unholy alliance with the royal governor of New York, the Earl of Bellomont.  The governor gave Kidd his support as a privateer, allowing him to command a private vessel as a ship of war.

            Privateers were only commissioned to capture ships of nations with which their country was at war.  Captain Kidd went way beyond this to capture ships of nations with which England was at peace.  Much of his ill gotten loot ended up in New York and in the pockets of his friend, the royal governor.

This Dutch thaler, minted in 1645, circulated in New Amsterdam. This was the first thaler I bought for my collection.

This Saxon thaler, minted in 1626, circulated in New Amsterdam.

After the English conquest of New York, English gold, like this quarter laurel of 1624, circulated in New York.

By the 1670s this half-crown would have been a  common sight in New York commerce.

Tom Rinaldo’s wonderful storecard features a New York Excelsion copper.

            In the end, Bellomont suffered a loss of face and Captain Kidd was hanged in London – three times to be exact. On the first occasion, the rope snapped. The second time the rope broke as well. The captain was a large man for his time, and there was a quirk in English law that said that  if the rope breaks three times, the condemned  man is set free.

            This was not the case with Captain Kidd on a fatal day in 1701. The third hanging was with a new rope, and the job was nicely done.

            New York would not know this swaggering pirate again.  But his gold and silver, no doubt, was still in circulation there. His gold doubloons would be matched 86 years hence with those of a native New Yorker, Ephraim Brasher.

            One of the most romantic coins produced in New York was the famed Brasher doubloon.  This is a coin I can only dream of owning.  It has been featured in books and films involving robbery and murder. It’s value today is approaching $1 million dollars at the very least.

This image of the Brasher Doubloon appeared in  the 1897 edition of Rare Coins with a value of 200 to 500 dollars.  It’s value today would be $1 million or more.

This image of a Nova Eboric Copper appeared in Rare Coins in 1897.

Rare Coins also featured this English-made token minted for Talbot, Allum, & Lee of New York.

            In 1979, an example of the coin from the famed Garrett sale fetched $725,000 at auction.  In 1981 another example from the same collection brought $625,000. Two decades later these same coins may fetch millions.  Don’t expect to find one in change.

            It seems that jeweler Ephraim Brasher lived not too far from George Washington by 1789 in New York.  For years before it was believed that Brasher forged the so-called Lima (Peru)-style gold doubloon. He then designed an attractive coin featuring the Arms of New York on the obverse and an eagle on the reverse.

            Brasher placed his touchmark, featuring his initial “B,” on the eagle.  This was to attest to the purity of the gold and the fact it was of correct weight. Too often people had been cheated by receiving a coin of lighter weight.  Clipping bits of metal off silver and gold coins was widely practiced. These slivers of gold and silver could add up to a tidy sum in time.

            Quite a bit of copper coinage was minted in old New York. Copper pennies featuring Washington, the Arms of New York, Standing Indians (A.K.A. First Americans), Eagles, and even George III were minted.

            Many New York copper coins were minted in England and then brought to the new United States. Among these was the famed “Nova Eborac” coins of New York. A head with a laurel wreath was on the obverse and a seated figure, looking a great deal like “Butannia,” was featured on the reverse.

            Copper coins minted for Talbot, Allum and Lee were minted in England with “New York” and without “New York” appearing on them.

            They featured a standing female figure with what appears to be a bale of trade goods on the obverse and a full rigged ship on the reverse.  Some Talbot, Allum and Lee tokens have lettered edges reading “Cambridge Bedford and Huntingdon X.X.”

            New York was to see the circulation of world coins for many decades to come.  A stock market was developed at the corner of Wall and Broad streets, and the rest is history.

            Tom Rinaldo, specialist in colonial coins, and owner of Yesteryear Coins of Phonecia, N.Y., has issued a wonderful copper storecard that should become a great collectible. The obverse looks like an “Excelsior” copper of New York, and the reverse is his business card.  Someday I expect to see these listed as the “Rinoldo Excelsior Storecards of 2000.”

            New York has a rich heritage of paper money. Colonial banknotes, broken banknotes, and banknotes for a lot of foreign countries have been printed in New York.  The American Bank Note Co., Hamilton Bank Note Co., and New York Bank Note Co. printed money, stamps, and other official paper.

   
Click Here for Larger View Click Here for Larger View

This “Miners and Planters” banknote of North Carolina was printed by the American Banknote Co. of New York in 1860.

This 10 dollar note was printed in 1861 by Toppan, Carpenter, Casilear & Co. of New York and Philadelphia.  This company also printed most of early U.S. stamps.

   
Click Here for Larger View Click Here for Larger View

This one dollar bill was printed in New York for the Merchants and Planters Bank of Savannah, Ga. in 1857 by Danforth, Wright & Co.

This beautiful Canadian banknote was printed by the New York Banknote Co. at 50 West St. This bank went broke sometime after this two dollar note was issued in 1861.

            New York  today is not only one of the greatest banking centers in the world, but the center of the coin business.  The heritage of numismatics in New York is a national heritage that reaches back almost 380 years.

            For those of you who want to catch up with me in the New Year, I’ll be at Richard Murphy’s N.E.S.S. Coin and Stamps Show on January 5, 2003 at the Holiday Inn in Dedham, Mass.  This show is held on the first Sunday of each month.  The Holiday Inn is located at Routes 1 and 128 (Exit 15A) in Dedham.  Show hours are 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.

            I have enjoyed meeting so many of you Journal readers each month.  It was great seeing so many of you for the first time at the Bay State Show in Boston in November.

            Have a  great and joyful New Year, and keep building those collections.

 

Journal Home Page     Contents Page     Brimfield FleaMarkets.Com     Brimfield Country Store     Subscribe